Colorado’s Death Penalty Is History

Old Sparky.

A major news item yesterday almost got squelched in the rush of updates about the coronavirus pandemic–as the Colorado Independent’s John Herrick reports, Gov. Jared Polis signed Senate Bill 20-100 repealing the death penalty in Colorado for cases beginning July 1. Separately, Gov. Polis commuted the sentences of the three remaining inmates on Colorado’s death row to life imprisonment:

The governor’s clemency orders, which reference the three men by their Department of Corrections ID number rather than by name, was in part based on Colorado’s new law repealing capital punishment.

“The commutations of these despicable and guilty individuals are consistent with the abolition of the death penalty in the State of Colorado,” Polis said.

But Polis also recognized that the death penalty reflects a long-standing bias in the criminal justice system that disproportionately punishes people of color. There are 539 convicts in Colorado who could have been sentenced to death, lawyers say. Only three have been. All three are black men. All went to Overland High in Aurora. And all were prosecuted in the 18th Judicial District, currently represented by District Attorney George Brauchler.

Monday’s order, Polis said, is “consistent with the recognition that the death penalty cannot be, and never has been, administered equitably in the State of Colorado.”

The debate over repealing the death penalty in the Colorado legislature was very dramatic this year as in prior years, and neither support nor opposition for repeal broke cleanly along partisan lines. A few Republicans voicing religious and libertarian objections to state-sanctioned killing were opposed by a few Democratic representatives whose lives have been permanently impacted by the commission of capital crimes–including by some of the very same murderers whose death sentences were commuted yesterday.

With that said, the state has been on course to eliminate the death penalty for years, going back to Gov. John Hickenlooper’s stay of execution for an inmate set to die in 2013. The high-profile failure by politically vociferous DA George Brauchler in the death penalty phase of the Aurora shooting trial was another watershed moment, demonstrating how the death penalty doesn’t work consistently even for the worst of crimes.

Given the personal nature of this debate to certain lawmakers in the Democratic majority, getting to this point was understandably difficult. But in a broader political context, the abolition of the death penalty is less risky in the long term for majority Democrats than allowing the debate over doing so to go on indefinitely.

And now for Gov. Polis it’s another campaign promise kept.

7 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. says:

    And good riddance to it.

    This one’s for Danny the Red(Hair), who tirelessly fought to abolish the death penalty. He should be here, virtually toasting this overdue result. 🍻


    • JohnInDenver says:

      There are several who kept hammering away at the issue, hoping to end sanctioned homicide as punishment generally and defending individuals to oppose the punishment specifically.  The effort has been going on so long that many have retired or died awaiting the resolution. 

      Hey Voyageur … who are a few of the memorable people you know from the battles over capital punishment? 

  2. spaceman65 says:

    Well, except for the death penalty case that the Adams County DA insists on pursuing still.  Trial is pushed back to April 6, but no word about death being taken off the table.  

  3. davebarnes says:

    "an inmate set to die"

    You mean Nathan Dunlap. Don't be a weasel. Name names.

    • spaceman65 says:

      He used the same language in each of the three commutation orders.  But only Dunlap has no more appeal rights.  Cases are currently pending for both Robert Ray and Sir Mario Owens, which will go forward regardless as they challenge the convictions themselves. 

    • JohnInDenver says:

      There's a pretty solid argument that "naming names" of offenders brings additional attention from people sympathetic &/or disturbed enough to choose to interact with the felon. 

      Some even start "romances" with the prisoners.

      Harder to do that with a number.

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account

You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.