Beyond Belief: NRSC Won’t Take Down Firestone Explosion Ad

UPDATE: Gov. John Hickenlooper’s campaign joins the call to pull the ad off the air:

Erin Martinez is absolutely correct — Washington Republicans must take down their ‘horrifying’ and false attack and stop exploiting this tragedy and distorting the facts to score political points.”

Here is the truth. As Governor, Hickenlooper held oil and gas companies accountable, levying tough fines for violations and implementing industry wide reforms. After the Firestone tragedy, Hickenlooper ordered companies to test pipelines within 1,000 feet of homes and implemented tougher disclosure rules for oil and gas companies. His administration also repeatedly fined oil and gas companies for millions of dollars for violating state and local regulations. The investigation into the Firestone disaster was started during the Hickenlooper Administration by the National Transportation Safety Board, and after it was completed in October 2019, the Polis administration levied fines.


The Denver Post’s Justin Wingerter reports via Twitter on a new ad from the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) attacking Democratic Senate nominee John Hickenlooper drawing horrified reactions:

Erin Martinez, with her husband Mark who died in the April 2017 Firestone home explosion.

Here’s the statement today from Erin Martinez, who survived the explosion in Firestone that destroyed her home and claimed the lives of her husband and brother:

I woke up this morning to hear about a horrifying political ad using images from the explosion and fire that destroyed my life and killed my husband Mark and my brother Joey.

My family and I have worked extremely hard to create positive changes that will keep my story from happening to anyone else and in doing so, honoring the memories of Mark and Joey. Not a single day goes by that we are not heartbroken and struck with unimaginable grief. This ad uses my story in a negative light and disgraces the memory of Mark and Joey.

Please remove this ad from public view immediately.

But in a statement this afternoon, NRSC spox Joanna Rodriguez says sorry, horrific tragedy survivor, but our ad misrepresenting the death of your husband and brother is not coming down:

The kind of grief Ms. Martinez and her family have survived is unimaginable, and their public fight to keep other Colorado families safe is incredibly important. John Hickenlooper said he was going to do the right thing to protect Colorado families right after the explosion, but then a private donation to his office from the gas company responsible changed that. He looked the other way and, as The Denver Post reported in October 2019, left office without getting the job done.

Let’s start with the central claim of this ad, that former Gov. John Hickenlooper “let them get away with it,” meaning that Hickenlooper let Anadarko Petroleum “get away” with the explosion that killed Erin Martinez’s husband and brother. The investigation into the Firestone explosion took years to complete, and it’s true that Hickenlooper had left office by the time the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) levied an $18.25 million fine against the company who bought Anadarko after the disaster. But to simply claim “no fines under Hickenlooper” as this ad does, without explaining that the fines did indeed come after Hickenlooper left office as a result of the investigations launched under Hickenlooper’s administration is an outrageous lie of omission.

The purpose of this ad is of course not to advocate for any Republican position on the Firestone home explosion or the fossil fuel industry. Anadarko and its successor corporate parent Occidental Petroleum are in fact six-digit donors to the same NRSC running this attack ad. Anadarko also contributed richly to Sen. Cory Gardner’s election campaign in 2014, and Occidential has donated north of $12,000 to Gardner in the current cycle. The NRSC is arguing in this ad that Hickenlooper should have gone harder…on NRSC donors.

It’s quite ridiculous, and that’s before you process how deeply offensive it is to run this deceptive ad over the objections of the survivor of the tragedy depicted. If Republicans want to demoralize Democratic voters by hypocritically attacking Hickenlooper on energy whole themselves bankrolled by the energy industry, that’s one thing. But this attack is hypocritical, mendacious, and exploitative of tragedy all wrapped up in a single thirty second TV spot. It’s breathtakingly desperate stuff, and we have to think it’s going to backfire spectacularly on the NRSC.

10 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. RepealAndReplace says:

    Cory Gardner – the man who will say "No" to the fossil fuel industry.

    Stay the course senator! Environmentalists will thank you.

    This reminds of when a group called "Republicans for the Environment" started trashing John McCain in his 2000 race against G.W. Bush. 

    • Conserv. Head Banger says:

      There was a group called Republicans for Environmental Protection that endorsed McCain for president. "Republicans for the Environment" ran into trademark issues if I recall correctly.

  2. JRRWIRED says:

    Gardner's version of a Willie Horton ad.  

    • RepealAndReplace says:

      Desperate times call for desperate measures.

      Especially since Cory lost the coveted endorsement from one of Denver's top two daily newspapers which he enjoyed in 2014.

      And that nasty commercial about Hick getting busted by the so-called independent ethics commission isn't getting the traction for which the GOP had hoped.

    • JohnInDenver says:

      NRSC  …  that's the "independent" campaign organization from the whole caucus, right? 

       * CHAIRMAN  Senator Todd Young (R-IN)

       * EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR  Kevin McLaughlin

      One question that leaped to my mind … what has the Senate majority party and its leadership done to make the energy infrastructure safer? 

  3. unnamed says:

    Um, so now Republicans are anti-O&G?  Did I stumble into a parallel universe?  The upside down?  

  4. unnamed says:

    Also, this reminds me of Bob Beauprez using Tom Clements' death against Hickenlooper.  Down to the family objecting to it.

  5. Genghis says:

    As much as we might want to tell children, "It's okay, sweetie; those rats are just playing," I think we can safely say that the ratfucking has officially commenced.

    • Diogenesdemar says:

      Next you know, those shameless dirty bastards* will be running ads with scowly-faced photographs of Hickenlooper . . .

      *(or, maybe it’s dirty shameless bastards? I don’t know — where’s fucking Yogi when you really need him? . . .)

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account

You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.