LGBT Ruling Shocks Gorsuch Haters, Proves Kavanaugh Fears

Justice Neil Gorsuch.

Politico helps us sort through another historic victory for LGBT Americans at the U.S. Supreme Court today:

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that the key federal law prohibiting discrimination in the workplace protects gay, lesbian or transgender employees from being disciplined, fired or turned down for a job based on their sexual orientation.

Two of the court’s Republican appointees, Neil Gorsuch and John Roberts, joined the court’s Democratic appointees to deliver the surprising, 6-3 victory to LGBT advocates. [Pols emphasis]

Writing for the court’s majority, Gorsuch accepted arguments that the Civil Rights Act of 1964’s prohibition on sex discrimination in employment also effectively banned bias based on sexual orientation or gender identity, even though few if any members of Congress thought they were doing that at the time.

“Those who adopted the Civil Rights Act might not have anticipated their work would lead to this particular result. Likely, they weren’t thinking about many of the Act’s consequences that have become apparent over the years, including its prohibition against discrimination on the basis of motherhood or its ban on the sexual harassment of male employees,” Gorsuch wrote.

It’s a decision being hailed as the most important victory for LGBT rights since the 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges ruling that invalidated state bans on same-sex marriage like Colorado’s Amendment 43 passed in 2006–and Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch’s role not just in voting to uphold discrimination protections for LGBT Americans but writing the majority opinion for the decision is scrambling a fair number of political circuits this Monday morning. Not least in Gorsuch’s native state of Colorado, where despite fierce resistance to Gorsuch’s confirmation from the state’s progressive majority and a record of judicial decisions that certainly justified their concerns, today his opinion is being celebrated by many of Gorsuch’s former opponents.

Not so for the other Supreme Court Justice confirmed during the administration of President Donald Trump, Brett Kavanaugh, who sided with the court’s two longtime arch-conservative Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas to argue the losing opinion that employers should be allowed to fire LGBT employees. Where Gorsuch has Coloradans feeling unexpectedly proud, responsibility in Colorado for Kavanaugh’s throwback opposition on this historic question rests with just one politician, the only Coloradan to vote in favor Kavanaugh’s confirmation–Sen. Cory Gardner. Gardner hasn’t said anything yet about today’s decision, and we don’t expect him to lest he offend either one side or the other of the coalition he needs to have a chance at re-election.

All told however, in an era of political cynicism here is a moment to oblige even the most cynical to recalibrate.

14 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. Gilpin Guy says:

    Kudos to Gorsuch for a glimmer of being reasonable.  It could be that he saw Roberts vote to win the case and tagged along to look good but it does make him look good.  Kavanaugh not so much.  Gardner also owns his vote for Barr, probably the worst Attorney General in the history of the country. 

    • Conserv. Head Banger says:

      GG: I think it's more than a glimmer. Remember that Gorsuch has also voted to uphold Native American rights, including one case in WY where the state tried to stop hunting "out of season" on the Wind River Reservation, which is a sovereign nation.

      • JohnInDenver says:

        Gorsuch has a pretty reasonable history with LGBTQ issues.  Apparently, he's had clerks who were gay.  One of them pointed out Gorsuch attended a open and affirming church in Boulder. 

        The opinion does allow for future litigation on issues involving employment which pull in other Constitutional rights.  Those were not a part of this case.

  2. Diogenesdemar says:

     Let me guess? . . .

    I haven’t yet had the opportunity to read the entire opinion . . .
    Coreless Gardner

  3. davebarnes says:

    On the other hand, the stock was up today.

    The gays is powerful.

  4. MichaelBowman says:

    Someone the evangelical movement has a serious case of the vapors today: 

    Conservatives Declare End Of The World After Gorsuch, Roberts Help Deliver Huge LGBTQ Win

    Varad Mehta, a historian who has written for conservative outlets like The Federalist and the Washington Examiner, suggested social conservatives would see Trump’s presidency as useless if his Supreme Court appointees don’t maintain partisan orthodoxy.


  5. Genghis says:

    Gorsuch is a dyed-in-the-wool textualist when in comes to statutory interpretation (i.e., the language of the statute is all Congress votes on and all the President signs, so that's all the courts can use). This ruling suggests that he'll at least apply textualism in a halfway principled manner and go where it leads him. I suspect it'll lead to "conservative" results more often than not, as originalism does in constitutional adjudication, but for today, chalk one up for the good guys.

  6. Duke Cox says:

    Maybe they are still in shock, but I am surprised the howling by the gun nutz hasn't started. The SCOTUS decision to ignore the 2nd amendment cases seems like a big deal to me. I guess we will hear from the gunnies tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account

You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.