Strange Case in Lakewood City Council Race

Michael Bieda

We haven’t talked much about local municipal races this year, in part because there hasn’t been a lot of terribly interesting news to discuss. Most city council races are fairly quiet affairs that don’t generate much enthusiasm — or many voters, for that matter.

But there’s a city council battle in Lakewood that is worth watching because of the unusual circumstances surrounding one of the candidates seeking to fill an open seat in Ward 3, (East Lakewood). Michael Bieda is a former State District Court Judge who lost his job in the 1994 election when voters elected NOT to retain him for another term.

If you’re not familiar with the process of retaining judges, let’s just put it this way: You’d have a better chance of finding someone to buy your solar eclipse glasses than you would of being ousted as a judge. Check out these statistics from the Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation:

Colorado voters elected to retain 1,312 of the 1,323 (99.2%) judicial officers standing for retention since 1990. [Pols emphasis] As shown in Table B, Colorado voters retained 99.7% of the judges receiving retain recommendations, 65% of those receiving do not retain recommendations, and retained all judicial officers where commissions offered no opinion.

Those are staggering numbers. Only 11 sitting judges have been kicked off the bench by voters in the last 27 years. Bieda is among those ignominious 11, and it didn’t take long for people to sour on him; Bieda was appointed to a District Judgeship in 1992 and was off the bench two years later. Bieda lost his job by 1,870 votes out of 126,216 votes cast in 1994.

Bieda served as a District Judge in the 18th Judicial District (Arapahoe County), where he took part in several notable cases, including the trial of Nathan Dunlap (the Chuck E. Cheese murderer). Bieda made enough waves behind the bench that he received a “Do Not Retain” recommendation from the Office of Judicial Performance prior to the 1994 election. Here’s what they said:

The Commission reviewed surveys and personally interviewed representatives from the criminal justice system. Most responses indicated that Judge Bieda has a poor courtroom demeanor, is arrogant, and has angry outbursts toward lawyers and parties. Judge Bieda received low ratings in his sensitivity toward witnesses and jurors. There are also responses that indicate that Judge Bieda is “unfair” in his treatment of women in his courtroom. The Commission is concerned that Judge Bieda’s hostile courtroom behavior has not improved over time nor has it changed with his transfer from the Domestic Division to the Criminal Division. Responses indicate that Judge Bieda has demonstrated an unwillingness to become proficient in his management of his criminal docket, and the handling of criminal cases. An additional concern to the Commission is the number of complaints alleging that Judge Bieda appears unprepared in his handling of criminal matters.

Bieda does address this issue on his campaign website, which you can read in full here. He says that he was targeted by attorneys who were upset that he didn’t let them charge more for their services, or something:

While sitting as judge, I created a pilot project to make the divorce forms with instructions easily available to those who did not want to hire a lawyer. This had never been done before. This project was so successful that the State Judicial Department adopted it and expanded it into the forms available today statewide through the state court system.

As you might expect, I was not popular with everyone, especially the domestic bar association. Because I helped people with the forms project, and because I insisted that the lawyers be prepared and efficient in their presentations, they were not able to charge their clients the outrageous fees they had been used to. Some of them organized a campaign against me when I came up for the election.

Because city council races are usually low-information, low-turnout affairs, it’s hard to gauge how much Bieda’s past will hurt his chances against opponent Michael Gifford. But getting kicked off the bench seems like a pretty tough negative for anyone to overcome.

33 Community Comments, Facebook Comments

  1. Early Worm says:

    I do not know Bieda and agree that it is a significant negative for a candidate to have received such a negative review from Office of Judicial Performance. But, I am a fan of Colorado's process for appointing and retaining judges. The fact that 99% of judges get retained needs a little more explanation.

    All judges have to go through a fairly rigorous (and mostly non-partisan) process in order to be appointed in the first place. 98% of undergrads at Harvard graduate. This is not because Harvard is easy. It is because the school self-selects for students that will be successful. 

    Also, judges are given their performance review recommendations months before those recommendations are published. Many judges, knowing that they are going to receive "Do No Retain" recommendations, retire or quit rather than face the ignominy of being voted off the bench. If you count resignations and retirements announced in the months preceding retention elections, Colorado's retention rate is probably closer to 95%.

    • NeonNurse says:

      Thanks for doing a great job of explaining this, especially the part about how many judges that learn they are going to get a 'Do Not Retain' choose to retire instead.

      I was on the Judicial Performance Commission for JD 15 for the max 8 years I was allowed. It's a fascinating (and indeed bipartisan) experience, and I highly recommend it to anyone who gets asked to be on one. This is real from-the-ground-up citizen involvement in action!

       

  2. FrankUnderwood says:

    So the Commission report included:  "There are also responses that indicate that Judge Bieda is 'unfair' in his treatment of women in his courtroom." 

    Perhaps President Trump will put him on the federal bench.

  3. spaceman65 says:

    He absolutely got what he deserved.  He was an awful judge

  4. sophiacharles says:

    I love the personality of Michael Bieda. He is a former State District Court Judge who lost his job in the 1994 election when voters elected NOT to retain him for another term Spirit Halloween Coupons 2017 . If you’re not familiar with the process of retaining judges, let’s just put it this way: You’d have a better chance of finding someone to buy your solar eclipse glasses than you would of being ousted as a judge. City council races are usually low-information, low-turnout affairs; it’s hard to gauge how much Bieda’s past will hurt his chances against opponent Michael Gifford.

  5. Lisaamanda says:

    Thats Good to be hearing here Thanks For More Helpful Tips Wolverine Origins Logan Jacket

  6. tamimayer says:

    PrintsAsia is the bookstore online that specializes in giving books as well as other printed book literature from the South Asian area. With the inventory of over 2 million famous book titles and encompassing wide network of the publishers over South Asia, and they’re poised to fulfill the demands.   Grab the offer before it turns out to be too late. https://promocodecafe.com/discount-code/printsasia-com/

  7. LisaAlix says:

    I like this author Michael Bieda and I also read this blog but you use this link catch coupon code.

  8. peterjohnee1 says:

    If you pay attention to what you currently have in life, you will get more of it. If you only pay attention to the things you don't have, you will find yourself never having enough cookie clicker for you.

  9. Conserv. Head Banger says:

    Pols: suggest you lock this thread, or delete it, since it's become "spammer heaven."

  10. MalenaMorgan says:

    This is really a very relevant post. Today’s students being future leaders of the country, this is a very important topic to be discussed cobra kai jacket

  11. Rodeobill says:

    If are a fan of Super Mario Bros, you can play for free online: https://supermario-bros.co

    Play world of solitaire for free online without download, install, or register.
    Website: https://worldofsolitaires.co

    And Word unscrambler online tool created to help you win word games with friends, and have fun.

  12. MichaelBowman says:

    We’ve had a breach, Alva 🤞🤞🤞

  13. MalenaMorgan says:

    I Really Inspired Your Posting keep It Up And Update This Type Of Marvelous Information. Suicide Squad Jackets

  14. schroedermckenzi says:

    It's so great! I have the same opinion as you! I have been following you and will be reading the next posts!
    Do you like playing game?
    It helps me reduce stress very effectively
    Let's play cookie clicker 2 game with me
    It's very funny
    Links: https://cookieclicker2.io/cookie-clicker-2

  15. RogerCrosson says:

    Thanks for the info about Michael. I think for many counties and cities it is normal practice for former judges or other politicians and congressmen to try to get into the city council or become a mayor. In the same case, I think he was rightfully removed from business in 1994. If in doubt, you can search Youtube for videos in which there are records of court cases led by this judge and see his reaction in these videos. I managed to find a couple of such videos there and I noticed that in most cases they had more than 14 thousand views! I am sure that in order to achieve such indicators, their authors have resorted to using the services of soclikes.com to quickly increase their number.

  16. Thanks For Sharing The Info. I really impressed your posting by keeping it up to date and updating this kind of amazing information.

    https://www.couponsexperts.com/stores/shein-coupon-codes

  17. juliancarter says:

    Wow Its A Very Helpful Thanks For Sharing. 
    Visit: Nadra Card US

  18. legendcole says:

    I really Inspire Your Post Thanks For the Info.
    Visit: Nadra Card Online UK

  19. arianna says:

    Sounds like the crooked, corrupt & incompetent Lawyers of Denver & the Denver metro areas (who are likely all Dumbasscrats) were just triggered because Judge Bieda made legal forms more easily accessible to people who can't afford legal help or those who don't want to hire an attorney, so they organized a campaign against Bieda to get him out. There was most likely voter fraud involved & all of our elections in Colorado should undergo a forensic audit like the ongoing one in Arizona & now Pennsylvania. 

    • kwtree says:

      Let me guess- you’re on Bieda’s re-election campaign? 
      I’ll take this opportunity to promote Rebekah Stewart for Lakewood City Council Ward 3! 

      I met Rebekah at a recent Jeffco Dems get-together. She is smart, compassionate, and will represent Ward 3 a helluva lot better than incompetent, misogynistic, fired-judge Bieda does. 
       

      Re: your “Dumbasscrats” remark: Bieda, a lifelong Republican, suddenly became “Unaffiliated” just before restarting his re-election campaign. It could have something to do with the demographics of his Democratic- leaning, working-class Ward 3. Bieda knows enough to try to at least seem “nonpartisan” – as his supporter, you might follow suit. Or not. It helps us, either way.

      Thanks for the reminder to send Rebekah money!

  20. lorrielsims says:

    The original title of a novella written by the Scottish author Robert Louis Stevenson that was first published in dustless floor refinishing seattle wa

  21. jamesstephen says:

    Thanks for the great website, but I wonder if you have any recommendations for Online forums. that discuss the same subjects as this article? This specific information was on my mind for quite some time. Tom Hiddleston Loki Jacket

     

  22. leeanjones says:

    Michael Bieda is not only great State District Court Judge but he is also a great advisor and I took all his advices and suggestions so serious all this helped me a lot to open viz apparel clothing manufacturer. He is amazing a amazing person.

  23. Genghis says:

    lol

    How did this lonesome 4-year-old entry become the go-to spot for spammers?

  24. RogerCrosson says:

    Thanks for the info about Michael. I think for many counties and cities it is normal practice for former judges or other politicians and congressmen to try to get into the city council or become a mayor. In the same case, I think he was rightfully removed from business in 1994. If in doubt, you can search Youtube for videos in which there are records of court cases led by this judge and see his reaction in these videos. And you can use the services of viplikes.net to increase the number of views.

  25. moyaitissue says:

    Thanks to the author's comprehensive description, I learnt everything I needed to know about my topic after reading this post. I published a review that you may read on the domyessay reviews. Thank you so much for your time and attention.

Leave a Reply

Comment from your Facebook account


You may comment with your Colorado Pols account above (click here to register), or via Facebook below.