Notable Links



Denver Internet Marketing by Parallel Path

Arvada Boutique Clothing Store Stella B's

Where Do Payday Lenders Locate? Where They Can Easily Prey on People

by: TheBell

Thu Feb 11, 2010 at 12:12:51 PM MST


( - promoted by Middle of the Road)

Aracely Panameno, the director of Latino outreach for the Center for Responsible Lending, was in town recently to meet with Latino community leaders. She presented them with the results of a recent CRL study that shows payday lenders nationally are nearly eight times as concentrated in neighborhoods with the largest shares of Latinos and African-Americans.

The experience in Colorado is much the same. Researchers at Colorado College found that payday lenders are more likely to locate in Front Range communities with higher percentages of racial/ethnic minorities, young adults, senior citizens, military personnel and immigrants.

In Denver, three council districts with heavy Latino populations are home to 83 percent of all the payday lenders in the city.

• District 1, represented by Councilman Rick Garcia, is 49 percent Latino and has 12 payday lenders, or 18 percent of Denver's total.
• District 3, represented by Councilman Paul Lopez, is 77 percent Latino and has 17 payday lenders, or 25 percent of the city's total.
• District 9, represented by Councilwoman Judy Montero, is 62 percent Latino and takes the cake with 27 payday lenders, or 40 percent of the total in Denver.

But Denver is not the only area where this pattern exists. Colorado Springs is home to 66 payday lending locations -- all of them clustered in 12 of the city's 56 ZIP codes. One of the lowest income neighborhoods has 19 payday lenders, or almost one-third of the city's total, and eight payday lenders can be found in one of Colorado Springs' highest minority neighborhoods.

Payday lenders are concentrated in six of Aurora's 21 ZIP codes, most of them with large minority populations.

That might explain why more than seven out of 10 Latinos in Colorado support proposals to better regulate payday loans and cap them at the state's 36 percent usury limit.

What is interesting is that most Coloradans feel the same way. More than six out of 10 Republicans, Democrats and independents support making payday lenders abide by the state's 36 percent usury limit.

Coloradans get it! They understand that charging more than 300 percent for a loan is just not right.

TheBell :: Where Do Payday Lenders Locate? Where They Can Easily Prey on People
Tags: (All Tags)


Why wouldn't they locate there?
Lower income people need to use payday loan shark services more than upper income people, so why wouldn't they locate in those areas.

I don't think it has to do with targeting easy prey, it's just targeting their natural customer base.

And, yes, there should be no exemption for payday loan services on usury laws.  If 36% APR is the limit, then it should be the limit for everyone.

"There's a Romney Rule. The Romney Rule says, let's double down on the tax cuts for the wealthy." -- VP Joe Biden


Agree that Payday lenders prey on people
so it's only natural they will be located where there are more low income workers and workers who don't use regular banking services. That's their target market.   Minorities, such as Hispanics, are over-represented among that demo. They aren't going to be located in Cherry Hills.  

It's an inherently predatory practice.
The Bell is casting a spotlight on that fact.

PR, I think you're making a false distinction between "easy prey" and "their natural target base." The two are one and the same.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


one thing's sure
 One thing worse than a payday loan is being unable to get a payday loan.

I don't think so
n/t

This is serious, you commie dolt  --davebarnes, 2012.

[ Parent ]
Only in the same sense that
the one thing worse than being sold heroin is being unable to find someone to sell you heroin.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
Where can I find this report?


Report(s) by the Center for Responsible Lending
Here is a link to the report

And here is the Center for Responsible Lending's main page for research and analysis on payday lending


[ Parent ]
Where can I find this report?


In related news...
...Bentley and Ferrari dealers are more likely to be found in rich neighborhoods.

People use this type of correlation to claim that Planned Parenthood is bent on black genocide by locating abortion clinics in poor neighborhoods.

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


Shocking. Just shocking.
I would have thought they would locate their stores in The Polo Reserves or Cherry Creek subdivisions.  Why in the world would they locate their stores where their customers reside?  I know..  I know..  it is because they are racist.  It has nothing to do locating near their customer base.


Ref C was pork without the fat.

Where on earth
are you a dcotor?

Not Colorado.  CBME has no record of you.  Why you'd post on COLORADO Pols as a doc eludes me.

Michigan?  You sound like a more aggressive version of Dr. Kervorkian, what with dancing on Murtha's grave one day, and now openly hoping for the early deaths of career politicians.

Do us real doctors a favor and go away.

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


[ Parent ]
He's not a doctor.
He's just a stupid fuck that periodically logs on to waste our time. If you see his name attached to a comment, do what I do--skip reading it.

"I wouldn't characterize caloric intake as "professional development." c rork

[ Parent ]
The Bell seems to have made a mistake
in assuming that people here would focus on their central point: Pay-day lending is a predatory practice, that exploits a weakness rather than provides a useful service.

Thus, my heroin analogy above. A heroin addict might insist that his dealer is providing a vital service, but there is a general consensus that the "service" exploits an addiction (a weakness), and does harm to the one "served." We can debate whether people should be protected from themselves, but there's not a lot of debate over the fact that heroin addiction probably does not, on balance, serve one's own interests in the long run.

No, there's nothing extraordinary about the fact that these "businesspeople" (predators) locate themselves near their "clients" (prey). By the same logic, MD and DP could dismiss a story about child molestors hanging out near schools and playgrounds by arguing, "Well, of course they hang out near schools and playgrounds! I mean, they're looking for children to molest, right? Where else are they going to hang out?"

Yeah, but, that kinda misses the point....

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


Yeah but...
...The story isn't about how much payday loans suck, it's about where they locate.

By my analogy, do you think women who can't get access to abortion from their private doctor have a right to access it?  If they do, shouldn't Planned Parenthood be easily accesible to them?

Anti-choice whackadoos make the argument that PP is bent on genocide by this correlation, when they really just don't like abortion in general for anyone.  They're argument is weak and so is yours.  You don't want payday lenders anywhere, but instead you complain about the specific locations where they are.

If payday lending stores suck, complain about their horrible practices, but putting your business near your prospective clients isn't evidence of nefarious intent, it's Capitalism 101.

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


[ Parent ]
OMG...
...I just spelled "their" ast "they're"

Hangs head in shame.

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


[ Parent ]
Um, no.
I couldn't care less if payday lenders lend to people who have tons of money. That is the point. The nefarious intent is due to who their clients are (as in the child molestor analogy), and that is what The Bell was trying to highlight. Since it is a practice which preys on low wage earners who never get ahead of the visious cycle of losing a large portion of their income in order to have it immediately (see heroin analogy), where the predators locate, and who they prey upon, is directly related to what it is that makes them nefarious.

Since providing counseling on reproductive services isn't nefarious, locating conveniently where such counseling is in highest demand (due to not having as much access to private doctors) is an actual service, rather than a predatory practice. That's the difference.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
Well again,
look at it from the opposite point of view.  

We may see access to abortion as an excercise in freedom and autonomy, but to the other side it's quite nefarious.  The poor. minority woman does not have the knowledge to seek out adoption agencies or groups who will help support her in raising her child.  Abortion is a quick fix, as she is left to the genocidal pro-aborts who are proponents of eugenics.

It can be argued that payday lending allows freedom and choices in the marketplace.  It may have negative consequences, but what freedom does not?  As she doesn't have access to credit counselling or a legitimate bank or credit card she goes to the outlet the market has made available to her.

Should the payday lending industry be heavily regulated? Yes!

Should there be incentives to locate traditional credit sources and good banks in low-income neighborhoods? Absolutely.

Are "free" markets the solution to societal problems?  Hell no!

But selling a legal product where your customers are is the market at work.  I would bet these neighborhoods have a lot more $1.35/scoop chinese restaurants and pawn shops too, and a dearth of Whole Foods.  Does that make Whole Foods racist?
 

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


[ Parent ]
We're talking past each other.
Here's what we agree on:

1) There's nothing wrong with services locating where they are needed.

2) Anti-reproductive rights advocates could consider reproductive services counseling to be predatory behavior directed against those who can be "persuaded" to commit what they consider to be an immoral act.

3) There are financial services that would be very helpful to low income wage earners, that would be very usefully located where payday lenders are located.

Here's what we seem to disagree about:

1) Whether something is a service or a predatory act is not a completely subjective determination. If one person considers, for instance, teaching math to be predatory, their opinion does not hold equal validity to that of a person who considers teaching math to be a vital service.

2) Whether something is a service or a predatory act is a crucial determinant in whether locating near the "client base" is benign or malignant.

I'm happy to agree to disagree with you, on those things that we disagree on.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
Fair enough...
But would you really be happy allowing 400% interest rate shops so long as they were only in Cherry Hills and Greenwood Village?

It sounds like you're more into abolition than zoning.

A woman's health decisions are a private matter between her priest and her husband.


[ Parent ]
If they only served customers
who could afford the loss without the same degree of hardship imposed on current clientelle, I would be far less concerned about it.

Look, as I said in response to someone else, I think the credit industry as a whole is mostly predatory. One of the first and most emphatic lessons my dad ever taught me was not to carry a balance on a credit card (which, if you pay the minimum, leads to paying about three times the price for everything you buy). But I am not in favor of prohibiting the practice.

Somewhere between the normal use of a credit card by people with an income that will eventually catch up to their debt (not always the case, as we all know), and the exploitation of the poor by predatory lenders, is a line between where individual choice prevails and legal protection against predation prevails. I don't know exactly where it is, but, for the most part, it doesn't pass through Cherry Hills.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
Though
the mere fact that anyone would accept that rate indicates desparation, and probably would lead to financial destitution in any case (eg, a Cherry Hills gambling addict). So, okay, you're probably right: It's the predation that counts. The fact that the most vulnerable victims tend to be low wage earners doesn't mean that they're the only potential victims, just the easiest ones to find and exploit.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
That's where we diverge
Payday loan services can, IMHO, be of use to society; they do not, IMHO, need to charge the exorbitant rates they currently force on their customers.

We've gone through the analysis here in the past; their customers aren't really any worse at repaying their loans than the average credit card holder.  Therefore, it seems obvious that they don't need to charge any more than the worst credit card rates.

"There's a Romney Rule. The Romney Rule says, let's double down on the tax cuts for the wealthy." -- VP Joe Biden


[ Parent ]
That's a reasonable position.
I don't entirely disagree (though, frankly, the credit card industry is predatory as well). I was referring to the payday lending industry as it currently exists, which is less a service provider than a predator exploiting a vulnerable population.

We're all in this story together: Let's make sure that we write it well.
http://www.steveharveyforcolor...


[ Parent ]
You can get cheaper money from a local loan shark
36% by rule of 72 doubles every 2 years.

judge elected officials by their actions, not by their rhetoric

A big part of the reason PD lenders exist are the banks.
Once upon a time, if you had $25 or $100, whatever the banks required to open a checking account, you got it.

Now they run a credit check and use a scoring system.  

As long ago as 1988 I was turned down from opening a basic account with Great Western in CA.........as I worked for them.

Payday lenders are picking up the slack.  Immorally, but meeting a need.

Part of the solution would be to require banks to open accounts regardless of credit rating.  They can protect themselves with other means.  

"Politics determines who has the power, not who has the truth." Paul Krugman, 9/2010


Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?







Advertise Here!
ads@coloradopols.com


Active Users
Currently 2 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search



Colorado Pols Network


Jeffco Pols
  More >

Denver Pols
  More >











RSS 2.0



Pols Gets Mobile: ColoradoPols.com/mobile/

Colorado Pols is on Twitter: twitter.com/coloradopols

Email Pols


How to Write a Diary That Will Make the Front Page



Terms of Use/Privacy Policy



Pols Posting Policies



The Pols Penalty Box



Yard Signs!



The Pols "Mailbag"

Mailbag #1

Relevant Links

The Bell Policy Center

The Big Media Blog

Blog It Right

Blog For Growth

Blogometer

Business Word

Colorado Capitol Journal

Colorado Center on Law and Policy

Colorado Democratic Party

Colorado Ethics Watch

Colorado Independent

Colorado Labor Blog

Colorado Veterans for America

Colorado Legislature

Colorado Lib

Colorado Libertarian Blog

Colorado Media Matters

Colorado Progressive Coalition

Colorado Republican Party

Colorado Secretary of State

Colorado Senate Dems

Colorado Senate GOP

Colorado Young Democrats

Commentary Today

Coyote Gulch

CU Democrats

Curious Stranger

Daily Kos

Dan Willis-Rumors

Dem Notes

Democracy for Colorado

Denver Politics

East Boulder County Politics

Ed Stein Ink

Election Neutrality Now

eleXn

George in Denver

Great Education Colorado

Head First Colorado

The Hotline Political Network

Junction Daily Blog

Left in the West

Liberal and Loving It

Maintain Educational Standards in Colorado

Mount Virtus

MyDD

National Journal

On Call

Peak Dems

Political State Report

Progress Now

Prometheus

Project Vote Smart

Radio Free Denver

Senate Guru

Slapstick Politics

Steam Powered Opinions

Square State

Stygius

TalkLeft

The Thicket

The Hypothetical Wren

ThomasMC.com

Toilet Paper Online

TRACER Campaign Finance

View From a Height

Walter in Denver

Wash Park Prophet

Western Democrat


Colorado Pols is wholly owned by Colorado Pols, LLC
webmaster-at-coloradopols.com

Powered by: SoapBlox